
Smoke Damage Insurance Claim — La Crescenta, CA
- Claim Type: Smoke Damage
- Property: Single-Family Home
- Location: La Crescenta, CA
- Claim Duration: About 12 Weeks
- Public Adjuster: Robair Sherrod
Claim Results to Date
- Insurance company's initial offer: $0
- Final recovery: $68,788
- Additional recovery: $68,788
Case Overview
On November 24, 2025, a fire inside the HVAC unit of a La Crescenta home spread smoke throughout the house, including the basement. Mercury denied the homeowner's smoke damage claim, stating that the smoke had not affected the property.
The homeowner was busy with work and unsure how to challenge the denial. After hearing about Avner Gat, Inc. on the radio, they hired the firm in March 2026. During his first visit, public adjuster Robair Sherrod immediately noticed the smoke smell and saw damage Mercury's original adjuster had missed.
The team helped the homeowner obtain an independent hygienist report and secured another inspection by Mercury. The carrier's adjuster agreed that the loss should have been covered. Mercury reversed the denial and granted approximately $68,788 in coverage.
Key Claim Issues Addressed
The denied smoke damage claim involved several issues:
- Mercury denied coverage, stating that smoke from the HVAC fire had not affected the home.
- The carrier's original adjuster missed smoke damage throughout the property, including the basement.
- Mercury issued no repair estimate or insurance payment because it had denied the entire loss.
- The fire originated inside the HVAC unit, and the system and ducting required inspection and repair.
The Challenge: Mercury Denied the Claim Despite Smoke Damage
Mercury denied the homeowner's entire smoke damage claim after its adjuster inspected the La Crescenta property. The denial letter stated that smoke from the HVAC fire had not affected the home, even though smoke odor and visible damage were present throughout the house, including the basement. The firm made sure the HVAC system and ducting were inspected and repaired, helping the homeowner move forward after the initial denial.
The Solution: Documenting Smoke Damage and Challenging the Denial
Avner Gat, Inc. focused on identifying the smoke damage Mercury had missed, gathering independent evidence, and securing a review of the carrier's decision. The firm also helped coordinate the work needed to address the damage throughout the property.
Identifying Smoke Damage Missed During the Initial Inspection
When public adjuster Robair Sherrod first entered the home, he immediately noticed the smell of smoke. As the homeowner showed him around, he also saw clear signs of smoke damage that Mercury's original adjuster had missed.
Mercury had denied the claim because it found that smoke had not affected the property. Based on the conditions inside the home, Robair recognized that the denial could be challenged. The next step was to obtain independent documentation of the damage so Mercury would have evidence to reconsider its findings.
Obtaining Independent Evidence and a Carrier Reinspection
Avner Gat, Inc. helped the homeowner hire an independent testing company to investigate the smoke damage. The company prepared a hygienist report, which was submitted to Mercury.
The report was important because Mercury had denied the entire claim on the basis that smoke had caused no damage. When an insurer takes that position, documenting fire and smoke damage can help establish what the original inspection missed. The independent findings gave Mercury additional evidence to review.
With the hygienist report available, Avner Gat, Inc. secured a return inspection by Mercury. This allowed the carrier to review its original decision against the independent findings and conditions inside the home.
Coordinating Mitigation, Contents, and HVAC Repairs
Avner Gat, Inc. continued working with the homeowner and Mercury's mitigation and contents vendors after the carrier's return inspection.
Because the fire originated inside the HVAC unit, the system and ducting needed particular attention. Smoke can travel through ductwork and spread to other areas of a house. If affected components are left unaddressed, they may continue circulating smoke-related contamination.
The team made sure the HVAC system and ducting were inspected and repaired as part of addressing the loss. It also coordinated with Mercury's vendors handling mitigation and contents, helping the homeowner move forward after the initial denial.
The Outcome: From a Denied Claim to Approximately $68,788 in Coverage
During Mercury's return inspection, the carrier's adjuster agreed that the smoke damage should have been covered. Mercury reversed the denial and approved coverage on the spot. The adjuster also apologized to the homeowner for the company's mistake.
The homeowner went from a complete claim denial with $0 paid to approximately $68,788 in total coverage. Mercury also reimbursed the homeowner for the cost of the independent hygienist report. Avner Gat, Inc. handled the claim over approximately 12 weeks, from March 17 to June 10, 2026.
What Homeowners Can Learn From This Case
This case offers several practical lessons for homeowners dealing with smoke damage or a denied insurance claim:
- Question an insurance decision that doesn't match the damage. If your insurer says there is no smoke damage, but you can see or smell evidence of it, the findings may deserve another review.
- Independent evidence can help challenge a denial. An insurance company's initial inspection may not identify all the damage. When smoke damage is disputed, an independent hygienist can investigate the conditions and prepare a report with additional findings. That documentation can give the insurer a reason to reconsider its original decision.
- Don't overlook the HVAC system and ducting. When a fire starts inside an HVAC unit, smoke can travel through the ductwork and affect other areas of the home. The system and ducting should be checked for damage, and affected components may need repairs to prevent smoke-related contamination from continuing to circulate.
- Ask whether independent testing costs can be reimbursed. In this case, Mercury reimbursed the homeowner for the hygienist report after reversing the denial. If you need independent testing to support your claim, keep records of the expense and ask whether reimbursement is available under your policy. It isn't guaranteed in every case.
Frequently Asked Questions Related to This Case
Can I Get a Denied Smoke Damage Claim Overturned?
Yes. An insurance company may reconsider a denied smoke damage claim if additional evidence shows that the original inspection missed damage or reached an incorrect conclusion. An independent assessment can help establish what was overlooked and provide grounds for challenging the denial. Whether the decision can be reversed depends on the damage, supporting evidence, and policy coverage.
What Is an Industrial Hygienist Report, and How Does It Help an Insurance Claim?
An industrial hygienist report documents findings from an independent investigation of property conditions, including possible smoke contamination. When an insurance company disputes whether smoke caused the damage, the report can provide evidence to support further review. In this case, Avner Gat, Inc. helped the homeowner obtain a hygienist report that contributed to Mercury reconsidering its original denial.
Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Smoke Damage to HVAC Ducting?
Smoke damage to HVAC ducting may be covered, depending on the cause of the loss, the policy terms, and the documented damage. Smoke can travel through ductwork and affect areas beyond where the fire started. In this case, Avner Gat, Inc. made sure the HVAC system and ducting were inspected and repaired after Mercury reversed the claim denial.
Can a Public Adjuster Help if My Claim Was Already Denied?
Yes. A public adjuster can review the denial, inspect the property, identify damage the insurance company may have missed, and help obtain evidence to challenge the decision. Avner Gat, Inc. became involved after Mercury had already denied the homeowner's claim. The firm helped document the smoke damage and secured another inspection, which led to the denial being reversed.
Was Your Smoke Damage Claim Denied?
If your insurer denied your smoke damage claim even though you can see or smell damage in your home, the decision may need another review. Avner Gat, Inc. can review the denial and help determine whether there are grounds to challenge the insurance company's findings. Call Avner Gat, Inc. at (818) 917-5256 to speak directly with the team about your claim and understand your options.